Blog: AI is used like an excavator, Zenia Stampe!
This is a blog post from Version2/Ingeniøren by Martin J. Ernst, a management consultant, written in response to the heated TV debate between politician Zenia Stampe and entrepreneur Martin Thorborg. In that debate, Stampe argued that AI models rest on theft because they are trained on art, texts and other creative work without permission or payment, and she told Thorborg he was not a real author because he uses AI. Ernst says he is on Thorborg's side but thinks Stampe has a point about copyright.
Ernst describes using AI as an extended arm, or a crutch for his weak written Danish. He has the ideas, experience and messages, and AI helps with drafting, structuring and researching sources, which he checks himself. These are tasks he once might have given to a secretary, editor or ghostwriter. By April he had written two books with the publisher Varius. His third, an e-book released in early June, came out about a month and a half after he decided to write it and has been downloaded by at least 500 people. He says that speed would not have been possible without AI. He compares AI to an excavator: it works faster than human hands, but a person still decides where to dig and what to build.
He identifies two copyright problems. First, who gets paid for the material AI models learn from, given that many models are trained on protected works, sometimes without rights holders having a real chance to opt out. Second, how to secure rights to what people create with AI. Copyright generally requires human creative effort, so output generated entirely by a model may not be protected, and the more of himself a creator puts into a work, the stronger the claim. He also worries that AI can lead someone to produce something close to an existing work without knowing it, and he asks whether his own tool, Værdikompasset, might do that.
The EU's AI Act requires providers of large general-purpose models to have a copyright compliance policy and to publish a summary of their training material. Ernst says this does not ensure payment to rights holders. He suggests a collective arrangement like Copydan, which pays rights holders when works are copied in schools and businesses, though he admits he also believes in Santa Claus. Until then he will keep using AI, while trying not to dig on other people's land.